| 4/18/99 - Urban
runoff a ruination for streams, fish -- One man's battle with
moss on a roof typifies the daunting challenges Portland faces to reduce
toxic plumes from residential use of chemicals. The scene unfolds like
this: One spring Saturday, during a rare lull in the annual monsoon, a
Portland-area homeowner sticks his nose outdoors. After months of watching
basketball from the couch, he feels a mighty urge for yard work. He quickly
discovers moss has invaded his lawn and wrapped his roof in a green blanket.
Ignoring his wife's plea to hire a professional, he climbs to the top of
the house and dumps several cans of zinc sulfate on his emerald foe. He
fails to check the label, which indicates one can is plenty. He doesn't
want to climb up there again.
As he finishes the job, the rain returns. The zinc sulfate, which is
toxic to fish and bugs, quickly pours through the downspouts and into the
storm drain in front of his house. The rain also carries away a thin spill
of motor oil on his driveway and residues from a pesticide he sprayed in
the dog kennel to kill fleas. Within minutes, the toxic household plume
dumps into the local creek. Once again, one homeowner's Saturday morning
has dented the health of a Willamette River Basin stream that once grew
steelhead trout. One resident's misuse of chemicals has little effect on
fish. But what about the impact of thousands of households in the Portland
area?
"Whatever you do in your garden and yard, in your driveway or in the
street in front of your house ends up in the Willamette or a tributary
of the Willamette," said Dean Marriott, director of Portland's Bureau of
Environmental Services. "The challenge is there are hundreds of thousands
of yards and driveways. Collectively, it can make a big difference."
Oregon's salmon debate has pivoted around hydropower, forestry practices
and cattle grazing. But last month's federal listing of Willamette Valley
chinook salmon and steelhead trout as threatened under the Endangered Species
Act brought the issue to Portland's yards and driveways. New research suggests
salmon may be especially sensitive to chemicals even when the fish only
pass through contaminated waters. A recent study in the San Francisco area
found toxic levels of a common insecticide flowing not from an industrial
section but from well-tended residential lawns. "When we first started
doing the sampling, it hadn't crossed anyone's mind that residential use
of pesticides was going to be an issue," said Jim Scanlin, an engineer
with the Alameda County (Calif.) Public Works Agency. "It came as a surprise
to everyone."
Toxic material in storm-water runoff has not been widely studied. But
few regulators underestimate the impact of urban runoff, which is ranked
among the nation's top pollution threats. Moss controls such as zinc sulfate
and copper sulfate can harm fish, says Jeremy Buck, a toxicologist with
the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Copper has been linked to disruptions
in the homing instinct of fish.
Operating a salmon-friendly household has become more challenging, said
Ross Penhallegon, a Lane County extension agent. "We have to look at things
differently," he said. "Putting things on the roof has never been a problem
before. The interconnectedness is what will drive everybody crazy. There
is no longer a single answer to the problem."
Toxic lawn runoff In the early 1990s, California researchers began investigating
toxic chemicals in storm water south of Oakland. Diazinon, an insecticide,
was showing up in San Francisco Bay after rainstorms. The federal government
banned diazinon from golf courses because it is a nerve poison that kills
birds, but the pesticide still is widely used; it is found in more than
200 products in California. Intent on tracking the pollution, the California
Regional Water Quality Control Board tested runoff in two cities, Hayward
and San Lorenzo. "We envisioned the problem was coming from industrial
areas low in the watershed," said Tom Mumley, a state watershed coordinator.
"But the problem was above. We tracked it all the way up to residential
neighborhoods."
The pesticide, an organophosphate, is among a generation of products
that replaced long-lasting chlorinated compounds such as DDT, which the
United States outlawed in 1972. DDT, which lasts for decades in the environment,
accumulated in the food chain and decimated bird populations. Almost everywhere
they looked, Mumley said, researchers found diazinon. The chemical hung
around longer than anticipated in aquatic systems and killed test organisms
at extremely small doses, findings at odds with industry studies that said
diazinon dissipates quickly, he said. "My assumption going in was that
one or two people were dumping things," said Jim Scanlin, who tested Castro
Valley Creek. "But it turned out it was coming from hundreds of sources."
Those sources were the residential lawns and gardens that drain into the
little creek south of Oakland.
What the diazinon problem portends for urban watersheds is unclear.
A report by Mumley and Revital Katznelson, a scientific consultant, says
the pesticide's impact is difficult to identify among myriad problems afflicting
urban creeks: massive erosion and habitat destruction spurred by flash
runoff; accumulation of nutrients and bacteria; removal of tree canopy
and higher water temperatures; and the presence of other pesticides and
heavy metals.
But the findings prompted California to organize a stakeholder's group.
Industry representatives, scientists and state and federal regulators worked
to reduce pesticide pollution. Mumley said the urban pesticide committee
has focused on public education. The group trains retail store clerks to
suggest less toxic alternatives in pest control. "There are some outstanding
issues here," Mumley said. "The evidence is sufficient that we better look
into what we need to do to manage this."
The Willamette Basin The U.S. Geological Survey gathered the best information
about pesticide pollution in the Willamette River Basin between 1991-95.
Fifty pesticides were found at 51 sites in the basin. Ten pesticides exceeded
federal clean-water guidelines for preserving aquatic life, said Frank
Rinella, an agency hydrologist. They included atrazine and diuron, which
are herbicides; DDE, a long-lived component of DDT; and the insecticides
azinphos-methyl, carbaryl, carbofuran, lindane, malathion, chlorpyrifos
and diazinon. The highest pesticide concentrations were found in agricultural
areas, although 25 different pesticides were detected in urban streams.
While the agency tested Fanno Creek, a Tualatin River tributary in Washington
County, data about urban storm-water runoff is scarce.
"There hasn't been a whole lot of monitoring in streams like Fanno or
Johnson Creek or these other urban streams," said Bob Baumgartner, water-quality
manager for the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality. He said urban
streams typically are dogged by high levels of heavy metals and an array
of problems, including excessive nutrients, high temperatures, pesticides
and heavy erosion.
Research in Puget Sound and Alaska by the National Marine Fisheries
Service shed new light on chemicals and salmon. Since 1987, scientists
at the service's Northwest Fisheries Science Center in Seattle have studied
the impact of contaminants on chinook salmon smolts in the Duwamish River
estuary. Scientists sample some of the smolts before they are released
from an upstream hatchery. Another set is collected three to five weeks
later in the estuary, which flows through an industrial part of Seattle.
"When we started doing this 10 years ago, we didn't expect to see very
much," said Tracy Collier, a fisheries service scientist. "We thought we'd
be able to show some exposure."
But the studies revealed much more. Even though smolts only briefly
passed through the contaminated estuary, their growth rate slowed, and
they became more vulnerable to disease when compared with fish moving through
cleaner systems. Collier said the suspect contaminants are polychlorinated
biphenyls or PCBs, long-lasting industrial insulators that now are banned,
and polyaromatic hydrocarbons, which are related to petroleum products.
The fisheries service has expanded that work into seven Oregon estuaries,
from Coos Bay to the lower Columbia. The sensitivity of salmon to polyaromatic
hydrocarbons raises a grim specter in urban watersheds, where oil residues
stream off parking lots and streets each time it rains.
Metro collects more oil products than anything else in its hazardous
waste program. During the years, residents have taken bags of DDT and even
radioactive uranium to the collection centers in Oregon City and Northwest
Portland. Metro collects 2.5 million pounds of hazardous waste and serves
about 30,000 customers each year, says Richard McConnell, a supervisor
with the program. He believes a broader effort is needed. "We are not hitting
the populace of this region," he said. "There is still a lot of hazardous
waste that is getting into our rivers."
In the Tualatin River Basin, 30 creeks violate federal clean-water standards.
One, Fanno Creek, the basin's most urban stream, is listed as impaired
because of bacteria, excessive algae, little dissolved oxygen, higher temperatures
and toxics, such as heavy metals. The Geological Survey study detected
23 pesticides in the creek. Jeffry Gottfried, a former president of the
Fans of Fanno Creek, once caught and released several cutthroat trout in
the beleaguered stream. Gottfried often hikes along the creek, turning
over rocks and hunting for signs of life. He says the creek is devoid of
the aquatic insects that healthy streams possess. "There is nothing there,"
he said. "We don't have a system that protects the creeks."
The region has achieved some gains. Since the mid-1990s, upgrades to
sewage treatment plants have improved water quality in the Tualatin River.
But experts believe more work is needed, especially on residential runoff.
"The potential impacts are so great, and yet there are a lot of unknowns,"
said David Moskowitz, Metro's salmon recovery coordinator.
"Much more public education is needed," he said, adding that development
of alternative products is critical. "There is no silver bullet." Source:
4/18/99, The Oregonian, by Brian T. Meehan |